Context:
This is the third visit by ICW to the village of Deir Ibzi'a,
west of the Palestinian city of Ramallah. Deir Ibzi'a remains
under closure by the Israeli Army, which maintains a checkpoint
and roadblock along the single road which connects the village
to Ramallah. The de facto closure of Deir Ibzi'a has been in place
since 20 February 2002, and since that time the villagers have
been forced to walk in the hills between neighboring villages
in order to reach taxis to Ramallah - the lifeline of Deir Ibzi'a
and at least 40 other villages. Today's ICW visit, in coordination
with the International Solidarity Movement (ISM) and the Hebron-based
Christian Peacemaker Team (CPT), had multiple purposes. First,
to reassess the needs of the village in terms of medical supplies
and other provisions and to report to Palestinian and International
relief and development agencies. Second, to be in solidarity with
the villagers as they demonstrate against the closure of their
village, providing extra security for them vis-à-vis the
Israeli soldiers patrolling the roadblock. Third, to go advance
the cause of villages such as Deir Ibzi'a to the international
media so that every effort will be made to alleviate the situation
of the villagers affected by closures, curfews, roadblocks, and
checkpoints.
Recent Developments in Deir Ibzi'a:
Deir Ibzi'a, like most villages in the West Bank, is outside Palestinian
Authority municipal areas (i.e. outside Area A). With the exception
of some agricultural products, the villages rely on supplies from
the main towns, Ramallah or Nablus, and from Israeli imports for
basic food items like flour, rice, sugar, powdered milk, as well
as utilities. But for the past three months, the village clinic
has not been able to open to serve the needs of the village because
the doctor could not reach the clinic. Villagers bring whatever
medical supplies they can with them when they make trips from
Ramallah, but more serious illnesses and emergencies present much
more difficult and life threatening problems. In April, one pregnant
woman from a neighboring village lost her unborn baby from complications
due to an injury sustained while traveling over the hills on her
way to the hospital in Ramallah. In late May, a woman from the
neighboring village of Qibya, which also relies on the Deir Ibzi'a
road to reach Ramallah, was not allowed to pass the checkpoint
to go to Ramallah for a scheduled kidney dialysis and died shortly
after as a result.
Several villagers spoke to us about the economy of the village,
specifically the problems related to the closure. Agricultural
products grown or raised in Deir Ibzi'a can only make it as far
as those adjacent villages to the west whose roads are not interrupted
by checkpoints or roadblocks. The fig harvest has just begun recently,
and due to the closure the price of figs has dropped from NIS
(New Israeli Shekel) 10 per kilogram last summer to NIS 1.5 this
summer because farmers have a limited market (US $1 = NIS 4.9).
In previous years, figs from Deir Ibzi'a were sold all over the
central West Bank and as far away as Tel Aviv. A ten kilogram
box of zucchini sells for NIS 7 in the village. By comparison,
the same amount of zucchini sells for NIS 40-50 in Ramallah because
of the shortage of crops reaching the market from surrounding
villages such as Deir Ibzi'a. Before the closure, the village's
chicken farm used to maintain approximately 40,000 chickens that
were marketed in Ramallah and other villages. During more than
three months of closure in which chicken feed was unable to reach
the village and chickens and eggs could not reach larger markets,
the number of chickens has dwindled almost to zero and cost local
farmers more than NIS 250,000.
For municipal expenses, Deir Ibzi'a is almost entirely self-sufficient.
As one village council member explained, all finances for the
upkeep of the school, the mosque, the roads, and the agricultural
fields come directly from donations and funds from Deir Ibzi'a's
1,600 residents. As the local economy suffers from the closure
and the loss of marketable goods and employment (which is largely
only available in Ramallah), the village is unable to meet budgetary
needs to maintain facilities and infrastructure.
In order to better connect the village to Palestinian infrastructure
in the cities and to promote the needs of the village, several
residents of Deir Ibzi'a are trying to establish a local NGO to
maintain social activities and foster employment in the village.
The villagers are acting through their own initiatives and by
their own funding to start.
(The ICW Report on Deir Ibzi'a dated 22 March 2002 contains further
details and analysis on the hardships faced by the village under
the Israeli closure).
Getting to Deir Ibzi'a:
Most of the international volunteers in Deir Ibzi'a made their
way to the village by hiking over two hills from the village of
Ain Ariq (between Deir Ibzi'a and Ramallah) - approximately 35
minutes. Occasionally, the Israeli soldiers patrol the hills on
foot to check the ID's and bags of villagers. On our way out of
the village, we witnessed three Israeli soldiers detaining ten
Palestinian men and two women more than one hundred meters up
the hill from the road and the checkpoint. The Palestinians were
made to open their bags for inspection and held for about ten
minutes before being released.
Several members of the international group approached the checkpoint
and roadblock along the road from Ain Ariq to Deir Ibzi'a and
were allowed to pass. But no Palestinian is allowed even to approach
the checkpoint on foot or by car, as the soldiers frequently fire
their guns in the vicinity of civilians if they come too near
the checkpoint. Some of the internationals arrived the day before.
They saw some soldiers check people behind the house and went
up to the roof to take pictures. Immediately the soldiers came
storming to the house and wanted to know who was on the roof.
When they saw it was foreigners they left.
Solidarity Action:
By 12:00 noon, more than fifteen internationals from ICW and ISM
had gathered at the home of Deeb Kamal, a Palestinian with German
citizenship who lives on the eastern hilltop of the village. From
his home we proceed to the village's central grocery store to
meet the delegation from CPT. We then proceeded to Deir Ibzi'a's
mosque where we held an informal village meeting in the courtyard
in front of the mosque. Most of the town's elders and the village
council were present. While we gathered, an Israeli Armored Personnel
Carrier (APC) drove up on the street adjacent to the mosque and
stopped for a few moments. As it attempted to turn around in the
road, many village children gathered around to observe. They made
"V" signs and stared at the soldiers, but there was
not any violent confrontation. The APC turned around and drove
back to the edge of the village.
During the village meeting, many villagers asked us about making
a demonstration to the checkpoint. The older men and women gave
specific instructions to the young children not to throw stones
or engage in any kind of activity that would break the non-violent
nature of the march. The international volunteers organized the
structure of the march, which included foreigners at the front,
followed by women and older men, and finally young men and children
at the back. From the mosque, we paraded through the village towards
the roadblock. By the time we approached the soldiers, the demonstration
had more than 200 Palestinian villagers behind the thirty internationals.
One volunteer from CPT approached the Israeli officer in charge
of the checkpoint to inform him of our non-violent action. Reaching
a compromise with the soldiers, the demonstration was allowed
to come within fifty meters of the roadblock where it was stopped
by a parked jeep and seven soldiers. Another three soldiers were
visible on top of the APC about forty meters up the hill about
the checkpoint.
At this stopping point, the entire procession of demonstrators
sat down on the road. One villager, Ali Othman, gave a speech
in Arabic about how the closure of Deir Ibzi'a affects the lives
of the villagers and other neighboring villages. The speech was
translated into English as he spoke. After he had finished, several
other villagers and internationals spoke about the dire situation
and the immediacy of the problems facing Deir Ibzi'a. Throughout
the sit-in action, the soldiers remained only several meters from
the group but did not make any provocations.
After almost an hour at the roadblock, we asked the Israeli officer
if he wanted to comment or respond to the many things said by
the villagers. He declined to speak. Then the whole procession
stood up and slowly returned to the village. Some villagers coming
from Ain Arik who could see the gathering behind the checkpoint
must have thought that now they might be allowed to pass and approached
the roadblock. But the soldiers sent them back. Some of the internationals
and the CPT delegation were allowed to go back on the road and
climb over the trenches.
Results and Summary:
The demonstration to the checkpoint and roadblock was chiefly
the initiative of the villagers of Deir Ibzi'a. More than one
told us that the village had wanted to do this kind of action
for a long time, but everyone was afraid of the reaction of the
soldiers in the absence of an international presence or media.
There was only a single international press crew on hand to document
the demonstration.
While the solidarity action and demonstration can be deemed successful
in terms of sponsorship by and participation with the village
community, the demonstration itself will do little to alleviate
the immediate suffering of the villagers of Deir Ibzi'a and the
tens of thousands in neighboring villages. Palestinians and internationals
both agree that this must become part of a broader effort to promote
the circumstances of Palestinian villages under Israeli closure
and work towards easing the conditions on Palestinians in conjunction
with the overall goals of ending the occupation of Palestinian
land and people. In particular, this means first and foremost
opening the roadblocks and checkpoints that dissect villages from
each other and from Palestinian cities so that economic activity
and medical and social services can operate without hindrance
or danger to the lives and rights of individuals. International
Checkpoint Watch joins the villagers of Deir Ibzi'a in demanding
the immediate removal of these blockades and closures of Palestinian
areas and easing the livelihoods of all Palestinians in the Occupied
Territories